
Football
Share
Published 10:49 10 Jun 2015 BST
Updated 16:07 10 Jun 2015 BST
Explore more on these topics:
Eamon Dunphy, Liam Brady, Johnny Giles and the late Bill O'Herlihy (right) in 2013.[/caption]
Let me start off by admitting that I have often bemoaned the current panel. On many occasions, the lads seem to be phoning it in when it comes to in-depth analysis.
They often prefer to go with their prejudicial gut and can tell viewers next to nothing about a player that does not earn his wages in the Premier League [or La Liga - Eamon Dunphy, having watched a game on Sky Sports, is the go-to guy on that].
Discussions often descend into character assassinations and rants about the lack of quality in the Premier League or why Brendan Rodgers should be sacked, even if the show is actually on a Champions League match between Porto and Juventus.
All that being said, I will tune into the match on Saturday, and the post-match analysis. The show, I know, will be the poorer for Giles' absence.
A criticism of Giles is that he is not up to date with all the top young talent coming through. That is a moot point as Giles has been blithely ignorant of upstarts for at least 50 years.
GILES ON GEORGE BEST: I played two games in the reserves with George before I left Manchester United to go to Leeds. George was only 17 - only a young lad. But the two matches I played in, he wasn't the George Best I saw 12 months later. So I didn't think that much of him. I thought he was okay, but by Christmas he was in the first team.
With the RTÉ panel, Giles, Dunphy and Brady are, more often than not, the show. Many fans will watch an Ireland or Champions League match on a rival station but tune in to RTÉ for the post-match discussions and arguments.
The lads, now marshalled, and goaded, by Darragh Maloney are an institution. They are much like The Late Late Show.
Keep an eye on Twitter and Facebook on the night of a big match and you will see the boys' names mentioned frequently in your stream.
Giles is often the peacemaker and the man who talk Dunphy back from the brink.
Without Giles, too, who will regale us with stories about Nat Lofthouse carrying his boots 186 miles to training after falling asleep on a bus to Brighton or about Billy Bremner swinging for a Jersey cow after a crazy weekend at Blackpool Pleasure Beach?
As for Richie Sadlier, he takes little crap and argues his points well, but can he hold a tune?
https://youtu.be/9tQCOryf_Hg
Sadlier, despite an undistinguished and injury inflicted playing career, is capable of offering insight, but goes against football pack mentality, showing that playing football at a high level isn't a necessary requirement for analysing it.
He also seems to annoy Brady, who can be dismissive of Sadlier's views, probably because of his undistinguished playing career, which makes for great television.
Sadlier acts as the voice of reason alongside the more established pundits, and although there's still a place for Giles, Brady and Dunphy, a younger, more progressive view is needed.
Sadlier doesn't provide soundbites like Dunphy, isn't as respected for his playing career as Giles and isn't as cranky as Brady, but he's intelligent and objective and a welcome balance to RTE's coverage.
Do you think RTÉ should keep Giles on the main panel?

Irish pundit had bad habit that did not please Roy Keane when he was his boss
This is brilliant! Kenny Cunningham is the gift that keeps on giving. While doing punditry work for the Brentford vs West Ham clash – which was won 3-0 by the Bees – the former Ireland defender told a great story about his time working under Roy Keane. Presenter Eoin McDevitt brought up the fact that […]
Football
2 days ago
How the Premier League table would look if every ‘VAR error’ was removed
It’s that time of the season again where you’re wondering if you’re better off or not without it.. Reflecting on your side’s season, you can always turn to the trusty VAR for an underperforming campaign. Every side has their individual case at some point though, we’ve all had major decisions go against us, and when […]
Football
3 days ago
Football
Quiz: Can you put these Champions League winning teams in order
Football